Amy chua parenting essay

Although Brooks and Chua have difference in tone and the way they use evidence to support their point, both of them rely heavily on evidence to argue the same topic. They would give up anything for their children. Hannah Rosin takes a distinctly different approach to success, one that is arguably more reflective of Western attitudes in general.

However, despite being raised by two Chinese parents, having two daughters of her own and authoring this essay, there is nothing that makes Amy Chua an actual authority on parenting.

What Do You Think of Amy Chua’s Way of Raising Her Children?

Although Chua appeals to readers' logic by saying that she uses the term "Chinese mother" loosely, there is a logical inconsistency in her elaboration.

To begin with, Amy Chua uses the Amy chua parenting essay technique. It is easy to notice that her tone is self-righteous. Amy Chua lists many proofs as evidences to prove her parenting practice is better than Western parenting practices. It is also interesting to note that to a poll conducted by the Journal, asking the readers to choose between "Permissive Western Parenting" and "Demanding Eastern Parenting," 13, On the other hand, Western parenting rather prefers nurturing children by following their feelings and emotions.

Chua says she is using the term "Chinese mother" loosely, which may reflect the motherhood practices of Korean, Indian, Jamaican, Irish, Ghanian, Pakistani, and Indian mothers as well.

She demonstrates an understanding of Western parents' concerns, but then moves on to explain why she thinks the Chinese method is effective and worth considering.

It is also interesting to note that to a poll conducted by the Journal, asking the readers to choose between "Permissive Western Parenting" and "Demanding Eastern Parenting," 13, Essay UK - http: She applies logos by backing up her arguments with surveys and statistics. However, despite being raised by two Chinese parents, having two daughters of her own and authoring this essay, there is nothing that makes Amy Chua an actual authority on parenting.

She is essentially saying that because she is Chinese, was raised by Chinese parents and is now a Chinese mother, she will have superior children.

Each of us is qualified to a high level in our area of expertise, and we can write you a fully researched, fully referenced complete original answer to your essay question.

In other words, the feelings or preference of the child as an individual are lacking completely from the Chinese framework of parenting.

Especially Lulu, who was the most difficult one. This is her use of the bandwagon technique. When parents spend time with their children and are involved in their activities, it is almost always a good thing.

Although, I may not agree with all of the aspects of this style, it does have its pros; such as wanting your child to the best that they can be and its cons; such as the belittling of a child can never be good.

The reason I disagree with her is that she defines the success of her children by accomplishments. But Chua is best in appealing to the rhetoric of pathos.

Chinese Mothers Controversy: Why Amy Chua Is Wrong About Parenting

Sad, but not always the case. When she says "I know some mothers of Chinese heritage, almost always born in the West, who are not Chinese mothers," she probably is not aware of the fact that she is insulting quite a bit of Chinese-American mothers who are proud of their Chinese heritage.

She has an excellent grammar and vocabulary skills, she uses an appropriate language in addressing her readers who are more likely to be Americans since it is published in American English and on the pages of Wall Street Journalshe is fair-minded, and she expresses a fair amount of respect for diverging opinions, especially in the follow-up response.

Some of her arguments are convincing, while others suffer from logical inconsistencies or fail to see a broader picture.

Strict, Controversial Parenting Style Leads to Death Threats for 'Tiger Mother' Amy Chua

Amy Chua has two daughters Sophia and Louisa. If so, why not talk about the "Asian mother". Parents cannot possibly always be in a position to know what will make a child happy or not; children must work out their own path to happiness Rosin, However, their purposes are different.

What Do You Think of Amy Chua’s Way of Raising Her Children?

Chinese parents take it a step further and do not allow choices for their children, whereas Western parents do allow their child to have choices. I am not completely comfortable saying that achievements or accomplishments are a true measure of success.

For example, it is great that Amy Chua spends a considerable amount of time teaching her child to play piano. Nowadays, many academic subjects require students having creativity, such as, visual arts and literature, how can the parents hope their children having good results without creativity.

When she returns to the cafe, she informs Lulu that she had won and she would be allowed to make her own choices and quit the violin. However, their purposes are different. We have all been raised differently, and most parents think the way they raised or are raising their children are the best.

However, the two approaches present a sharp contrast to each other.

Free English Literature essays

In fact, according to Dr. I define parental success by happiness, not accomplishments. Parenting: Amy Chua vs. Hanna Rosin Is there a right way to raise your child? There are really no set rules on how to raise your child, as we can see throughout the articles written by Amy Chua, a self-described “Chinese Tiger Mom” and Hanna Rosin, a “Western Mother,” in The Wall Street Journal in January Amy Chua calls herself a 'Tiger Mother' because of her strict parenting methods that didn't allow for play dates or sleepovers for her two daughters.

But her essay in the Wall Street Journal has. Amy Chua - Why Chinese Mother's Are Superior. 4 Pages Words December Saved essays Amy Chua uses provocation and irony to draw in the reader; just by naming the article something, which questions the western readers parenting.

The list she has created in the top shows us the irony. In “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior”, Amy Chua discusses the effectiveness of her parenting style.

This is an excerpt from Amy Chua’s book Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother. According to Behrens and Rosen, “the title “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” was written by the editors of the [Wall Street] Journal, not by Chua, most likely. This free English Literature essay on Essay: Amy Chua - 'Why Chinese mothers are superior', and David Brooks, 'Amy Chua is a Wimp' is perfect for English Literature students to use as an example.

"Chinese Parenting Or Western Parenting" Essays and Research Papers. Chinese Parenting Or Western Parenting. Amy Chua Stereotypes Parenting What makes a child excel?

Amy Chua, in her work “Why Chinese Mothers are Superior”, writes to inform her.

Amy chua parenting essay
Rated 4/5 based on 11 review
Parenting is Personal: "Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother" by Amy Chua - Papers & Essays